GTA6 ArchivesBlog
All posts

GTA: do violent video games cause violence?

· 9 min read · GTA6 Archives

What research says about games like GTA, aggression and violence. The APA's 2020 resolution, the main meta-analyses on both sides, and the Supreme Court.

Do violent video games like GTA cause violence? The research does not show that they do. The American Psychological Association says that attributing violence to violent video gaming "is not scientifically sound". What researchers still argue about is a smaller question: whether violent games are linked to milder aggression, such as pushing or insults, and whether that link is large enough to matter.

This post sets out both sides using the papers and statements themselves. None of them studied GTA 6, which came out on 19 November 2026. They studied violent games as a category, mostly in children, teenagers and students.

Aggression and violence are not the same thing

Most confusion on this topic comes from two words being used as if they were one.

The APA's resolution on violent video games, revised in February 2020, separates them. In psychological research, it says, aggression "is usually conceptualized as behavior that is intended to harm another". Violence "can be defined as an extreme form of aggression", or the intentional use of physical force that results in, or is highly likely to result in, harm.

The resolution sums it up: "all violence, including lethal violence, is aggression, but not all aggression is violence."

This matters because of what the studies measured. The resolution lists the outcomes: laboratory stand-ins such as "the administration of a noise blast" to another person, plus questionnaires, peer nominations and teacher ratings covering "insults, threats, hitting, pushing, hair pulling, biting and other forms of verbal and physical aggression".

Those are not crimes. The resolution says the literature "has not focused on lethal violence as an outcome".

What the APA says about violent video games and violence

The 2020 revision opens with a warning about how the resolution had been used. It "should not be misinterpreted or misused by attributing violence, such as mass shootings, to violent video game use". It continues: "Violence is a complex social problem that likely stems from many factors". And it states: "Insufficient research has examined whether violent video game use causes lethal violence."

The same document does not clear violent games of every effect. It finds that research "has demonstrated an association between violent video game use and both increases in aggressive behavior, aggressive affect, aggressive cognitions and decreases in prosocial behavior, empathy, and moral engagement". It calls violent game use "one such risk factor" among many.

It also gives the size of the effects from four earlier reviews: 0.19, 0.15, 0.08 and 0.16. The resolution notes that these numbers are similar, but that "the interpretations of these effects have varied dramatically".

And it lists what is missing. Very little research has included children younger than 10. Research "has not adequately examined" whether the association differs for males and females, and has not sufficiently examined ethnicity, socioeconomic status or culture.

So the APA position has two halves. There is an association with aggression. There is not evidence to blame games for violence.

Meta-analyses on violent video games: the two sides

The review that found an effect: Anderson and colleagues, 2010

A meta-analysis pools the results of many studies. The best known one on this topic was published in Psychological Bulletin in 2010 by Craig Anderson and seven co-authors.

It tested the effects of violent games on six outcomes: aggressive behaviour, aggressive thoughts, aggressive feelings, physiological arousal, empathy and prosocial behaviour. It included experiments, cross-sectional surveys and longitudinal studies, from Japan and from Western countries. A later paper in PNAS describes it as covering over 130 research reports and over 130,000 participants.

Its conclusion is firm: "The evidence strongly suggests that exposure to violent video games is a causal risk factor for increased aggressive behavior, aggressive cognition, and aggressive affect and for decreased empathy and prosocial behavior." The authors reported "little evidence" of publication bias.

Note the wording. The claim is about a "risk factor" for aggressive behaviour. The abstract does not say violent games cause violent crime.

The critics: Ferguson's objections and his own numbers

The psychologist Christopher Ferguson is a leading critic of that conclusion. The 2018 PNAS paper, whose authors disagree with him, summarises his objections as four points:

  1. Many studies use measures of "nonserious aggression", such as how quickly aggression-related words come to mind, which inflate the results.
  2. Many studies leave out other variables that could explain the link.
  3. Journals are more likely to publish studies that find a link than studies that find nothing.
  4. Even if the link is real, the effect "is exceedingly weak".

Ferguson published his own meta-analysis in Perspectives on Psychological Science in 2015. It looked only at studies of children and adolescents, 101 in total, and at video games overall as well as violent ones. It reported an effect on increased aggression of r = .06, along with similarly small figures for prosocial behaviour, school performance, depressive symptoms and attention problems. Its abstract calls these influences "minimal" and says "publication bias remains a problem for studies of aggression".

Newer studies: one found a link, one did not

Following children over time: Prescott, Sargent and Hull, 2018

This meta-analysis, published in PNAS, was designed to answer Ferguson's objections. It used only studies that measured violent game play at one time and real-world physical aggression later, while accounting for how aggressive each child already was.

  • What it pooled. 24 studies with more than 17,000 participants, from countries including the United States, Canada, Germany, Japan and Singapore.
  • Who. Children and teenagers, with average ages from about 9 to 19.
  • How long. Gaps of 3 months to 4 years between measurements.
  • What counted as aggression. Overt physical aggression, mostly self-reported. One study's measure, for example, was hitting non-family members and being sent to the school office for fighting.

The result was a positive association, with a standardized coefficient of about 0.11. With every extra control variable included, it fell to about 0.08 and remained statistically significant. The authors found no evidence of publication bias.

The authors call this a "modest effect size". They also report Ferguson's reply to numbers like it, that a coefficient of 0.10 is associated with "only 1% of the variance in the outcome". Their answer is that small effects on antisocial behaviour can still matter, and that "a statistically significant, reliable effect exists in the literature".

Two limits come from the paper itself. Every study measured how much violent gaming children already did; none assigned children to play. That design cannot settle cause as an experiment would. And the effect differed by group: it was largest in mostly White samples, intermediate in Asian samples and not significant in Hispanic samples.

A preregistered study that found nothing: Przybylski and Weinstein, 2019

Andrew Przybylski and Netta Weinstein published this study in Royal Society Open Science as a registered report. That means the analysis plan was fixed and reviewed before the data were analysed, which limits the room to pick favourable results afterwards.

  • Who. 1,004 British adolescents aged 14 and 15, and an equal number of their carers.
  • How violent play was measured. Teenagers listed the games they had played recently. The researchers coded violence from official ratings, the European PEGI system and, in an additional analysis, the American ESRB.
  • How aggression was measured. Carers, not the teenagers, rated the teenager's aggressive behaviour over the past month.

Violent games were common in the sample. The paper reports that 68.0% of boys and 48.8% of girls had played at least one in the past month.

The hypothesis was that more violent game play would go with more aggression as rated by carers. The abstract says: "Results did not support this prediction". The authors also found "no evidence for a critical tipping point" above which violent play became linked to aggression.

The authors state the limits. The study "is based on cross-sectional data", a single snapshot, so it cannot show whether effects build up over years. They also write that they could not rule out a correlation under every possible way of measuring gaming.

What the US Supreme Court said about the evidence

In Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association, decided on 27 June 2011, the Supreme Court struck down a California law that banned the sale or rental of violent video games to minors, with fines of up to $1,000.

The decision was about free speech, not psychology. But the opinion, written by Justice Scalia, assessed the studies California relied on, chiefly Dr. Craig Anderson's. The Court said they "do not prove that violent video games cause minors to act aggressively". Quoting a lower court, it added that "nearly all of the research is based on correlation, not evidence of causation".

The Court described the effects shown as "both small and indistinguishable from effects produced by other media". It noted Dr. Anderson's testimony that similar effects had been found when children watch cartoons "starring Bugs Bunny or the Road Runner".

Two cautions apply. A court ruling is a legal judgment about whether evidence was strong enough to justify restricting speech, not a scientific finding. And it dates from 2011, before the 2018 and 2019 studies above. Justice Alito concurred in the result only, and Justices Thomas and Breyer dissented.

What this means for a game like GTA 6

Staying within what the sources say:

  • No source here shows that playing violent games causes violent crime. The APA says attributing violence to violent gaming is not scientifically sound.
  • Several reviews find a small statistical link between violent games and milder aggression. The APA treats violent game use as one risk factor among many.
  • Researchers disagree on whether that link is causal and whether it is large enough to matter. A large preregistered study of British teenagers found no link.
  • Children under 10 are barely covered by the research, according to the APA.
  • GTA 6 itself has not been studied.

The research is about effects on players. Whether a game is suitable for a particular child is a different question, and rating boards answer it by describing content. Our GTA 6 age rating guide for parents lists what the boards say is in the game.

Related questions

Does GTA make you violent?

No study in this post tested GTA specifically. For violent games as a category, the APA says there is an association with aggressive outcomes and that attributing violence to violent video gaming "is not scientifically sound". Aggression in these studies means things like insults, pushing and hitting, measured by questionnaires or lab tasks.

Has the APA changed its position on violent video games?

It revised its 2015 resolution in February 2020. The revision kept the finding of an association between violent game use and aggressive outcomes, and added an opening caution that the resolution should not be used to attribute violence, such as mass shootings, to violent video games.

Why do scientists disagree if the numbers are similar?

The APA resolution notes that four reviews produced effect sizes of 0.19, 0.15, 0.08 and 0.16, yet were interpreted very differently. One side argues that a small, reliable effect across many children matters. The other argues that it is too weak to mean much and is inflated by weak measures and publication bias.

Do violent games affect why people enjoy playing?

That is a separate line of research, about motivation and not harm. Our post on why GTA is so addictive covers studies that found violent content added little to enjoyment once players' sense of choice and skill was accounted for.

If you make videos, how platforms treat game violence is a separate policy question, covered in our post on GTA 6 violence and YouTube ad rules. To check any claim here, open the paper in the source list and read its abstract and limitations section. Each one states what it measured and in whom.

Sources

Checked against these sources on 21 November 2026. Policies, prices and release details change; if a source has been updated since, the source wins. GTA6 Archives is independent and not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two.

Keep reading

40% off with GTALAUNCH40